Copyright, trespass and constructive trusts: Australia’s Top Court clarifies copyright ownership of unlawfully obtained footage
Published 15 November 2026
Matthew Murphy
On 11 November 2026, in Farm Transparency International Ltd v The Game Meats Company of Australia Pty Ltd [2026] HCA 42, the High Court of Australia delivered an important judgment on the intersection of copyright ownership, equitable remedies and unlawful conduct.
The case arose from video footage obtained by Farm Transparency International Ltd (Farm Transparency) through unauthorised entry onto premises operated by The Game Meats Company of Australia Pty Ltd (Game Meats). Although the footage had been obtained unlawfully, Farm Transparency claimed copyright in the recordings under the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth).
The central question before the High Court was whether Farm Transparency's unlawful conduct justified the imposition of a constructive trust over the copyright in favour of Game Meats. Such a trust would have required Farm Transparency to hold its copyright interest for the benefit of Game Meats, effectively separating legal ownership from beneficial ownership.
The High Court allowed Farm Transparency's appeal on this issue, overturning the Full Federal Court's conclusion that the copyright was held on constructive trust for Game Meats. Farm Transparency consequently retained its copyright interest, notwithstanding the unlawful circumstances in which the footage had been obtained.
Importantly, however, the Court's decision did not excuse the underlying trespass or prevent remedies directed at the unlawfully obtained recordings. Farm Transparency remained subject to orders requiring the deletion or destruction of the relevant footage.
The judgment therefore draws an important distinction between the ownership of copyright under statute and the availability of equitable or other remedies for unlawful conduct associated with the creation of copyright material.
It also raises broader questions concerning the circumstances in which courts may impose proprietary remedies over intellectual property, particularly where the relevant rights arise from conduct that infringes another person's legal interests. Background to the dispute Farm Transparency is an animal welfare organisation engaged in documenting and publicising practices within the Australian agricultural and meat-processing industries. Its activities include obtaining and disseminating footage of animal treatment at commercial facilities.
Between January and April 2024, persons acting on behalf of Farm Transparency entered Game Meats' abattoir in Victoria without permission. During those entries, hidden cameras were installed and subsequently retrieved. The cameras recorded activities occurring within the facility, and Farm Transparency intended to use the resulting footage to inform the public about animal welfare practices.
The footage was subsequently incorporated into material made available to the public, including through a television broadcast and publication on Farm Transparency's website.
Game Meats commenced proceedings in the Federal Court, seeking relief arising from the trespasses and the publication of the recordings. The proceedings raised not only questions concerning compensation for trespass but also whether Game Meats could prevent further use of the footage and obtain beneficial ownership of the associated copyright.
Proceedings before the Federal Court At first instance, the Federal Court awarded Game Meats general and exemplary damages for the trespasses. However, the primary judge declined to impose a constructive trust over the copyright in the recordings or to grant the permanent injunctive relief sought by Game Meats.
On appeal, the Full Court of the Federal Court adopted a different approach.
The Full Court concluded that Farm Transparency held the copyright in the footage on constructive trust for Game Meats. It also ordered Farm Transparency to execute an assignment of the copyright and made consequential orders restricting publication and requiring deletion of the recordings.
The effect of those orders was significant. Rather than merely preventing Farm Transparency from exploiting material obtained through trespass, the constructive trust provided Game Meats with a proprietary interest in the copyright itself. This potentially enabled Game Meats to enforce copyright rights against third parties who might subsequently reproduce or communicate the footage.
Farm Transparency appealed to the High Court, challenging both the imposition of the constructive trust and the consequential orders.
The High Court's decision The High Court unanimously allowed the appeal in part, holding that the constructive trust imposed by the Full Federal Court was not an appropriate remedy in the circumstances.
The Court recognised that the trespasses were deliberate and that damages alone were insufficient to address their continuing consequences. However, it distinguished between the need to remedy those consequences and the much more extensive step of transferring beneficial ownership of copyright to Game Meats.
A constructive trust is a proprietary remedy with consequences extending beyond the immediate parties. In this case, its imposition would have provided Game Meats with rights associated with copyright ownership, including the potential to pursue third parties for copyright infringement.
The High Court considered that such an extensive remedy was unnecessary when more limited injunctive relief could adequately address the consequences of Farm Transparency's unlawful conduct.
The Court therefore set aside the declaration of constructive trust and the associated assignment requirement. It nevertheless ordered Farm Transparency to permanently delete or destroy the relevant images and copies within its possession or control, including copies that might come into its possession or control in the future.
The orders also required affidavits confirming compliance and imposed restrictions on publication or communication pending compliance.
Copyright ownership and unlawful conduct One of the most important aspects of the judgment is its treatment of the relationship between copyright ownership and the circumstances in which copyright material is created.
Under the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth), copyright ownership is determined by statutory rules concerning authorship, creation and ownership. The fact that a work is created in circumstances involving unlawful conduct does not necessarily mean that copyright fails to arise or automatically becomes the property of the person affected by that conduct.
The High Court's decision illustrates that distinction.
Farm Transparency's trespass provided a basis for legal remedies in favour of Game Meats. However, the existence of that wrong did not, without more, justify treating Game Meats as the beneficial owner of the copyright.
The Court's reasoning does not establish that a constructive trust can never be imposed over copyright created through unlawful activity. Rather, it emphasises the importance of identifying an appropriate equitable basis for such relief and considering whether a less intrusive remedy can adequately resolve the dispute.
This is particularly significant because a constructive trust may alter proprietary rights in ways that extend beyond the correction of the original wrongdoing. The importance of proportionality in equitable remedies The judgment also reinforces the principle that equitable relief should be tailored to the circumstances of the particular case.
Although equity may intervene where damages are inadequate, the availability of an equitable remedy does not mean that the most extensive form of relief should necessarily be granted.
In the present case, Game Meats had a legitimate interest in preventing the continued possession and exploitation of footage obtained through trespass. However, that interest could be protected through mandatory orders requiring deletion or destruction of the recordings.
Transferring beneficial ownership of the copyright was therefore unnecessary to achieve an appropriate remedial outcome.
The decision highlights the distinction between remedies designed to prevent the continuing consequences of unlawful conduct and remedies that confer proprietary rights on the injured party.
It also demonstrates that retaining copyright ownership does not necessarily confer a practical entitlement to retain, reproduce, publish or otherwise exploit the underlying material.
The case arose from video footage obtained by Farm Transparency International Ltd (Farm Transparency) through unauthorised entry onto premises operated by The Game Meats Company of Australia Pty Ltd (Game Meats). Although the footage had been obtained unlawfully, Farm Transparency claimed copyright in the recordings under the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth).
The central question before the High Court was whether Farm Transparency's unlawful conduct justified the imposition of a constructive trust over the copyright in favour of Game Meats. Such a trust would have required Farm Transparency to hold its copyright interest for the benefit of Game Meats, effectively separating legal ownership from beneficial ownership.
The High Court allowed Farm Transparency's appeal on this issue, overturning the Full Federal Court's conclusion that the copyright was held on constructive trust for Game Meats. Farm Transparency consequently retained its copyright interest, notwithstanding the unlawful circumstances in which the footage had been obtained.
Importantly, however, the Court's decision did not excuse the underlying trespass or prevent remedies directed at the unlawfully obtained recordings. Farm Transparency remained subject to orders requiring the deletion or destruction of the relevant footage.
The judgment therefore draws an important distinction between the ownership of copyright under statute and the availability of equitable or other remedies for unlawful conduct associated with the creation of copyright material.
It also raises broader questions concerning the circumstances in which courts may impose proprietary remedies over intellectual property, particularly where the relevant rights arise from conduct that infringes another person's legal interests. Background to the dispute Farm Transparency is an animal welfare organisation engaged in documenting and publicising practices within the Australian agricultural and meat-processing industries. Its activities include obtaining and disseminating footage of animal treatment at commercial facilities.
Between January and April 2024, persons acting on behalf of Farm Transparency entered Game Meats' abattoir in Victoria without permission. During those entries, hidden cameras were installed and subsequently retrieved. The cameras recorded activities occurring within the facility, and Farm Transparency intended to use the resulting footage to inform the public about animal welfare practices.
The footage was subsequently incorporated into material made available to the public, including through a television broadcast and publication on Farm Transparency's website.
Game Meats commenced proceedings in the Federal Court, seeking relief arising from the trespasses and the publication of the recordings. The proceedings raised not only questions concerning compensation for trespass but also whether Game Meats could prevent further use of the footage and obtain beneficial ownership of the associated copyright.
Proceedings before the Federal Court At first instance, the Federal Court awarded Game Meats general and exemplary damages for the trespasses. However, the primary judge declined to impose a constructive trust over the copyright in the recordings or to grant the permanent injunctive relief sought by Game Meats.
On appeal, the Full Court of the Federal Court adopted a different approach.
The Full Court concluded that Farm Transparency held the copyright in the footage on constructive trust for Game Meats. It also ordered Farm Transparency to execute an assignment of the copyright and made consequential orders restricting publication and requiring deletion of the recordings.
The effect of those orders was significant. Rather than merely preventing Farm Transparency from exploiting material obtained through trespass, the constructive trust provided Game Meats with a proprietary interest in the copyright itself. This potentially enabled Game Meats to enforce copyright rights against third parties who might subsequently reproduce or communicate the footage.
Farm Transparency appealed to the High Court, challenging both the imposition of the constructive trust and the consequential orders.
The High Court's decision The High Court unanimously allowed the appeal in part, holding that the constructive trust imposed by the Full Federal Court was not an appropriate remedy in the circumstances.
The Court recognised that the trespasses were deliberate and that damages alone were insufficient to address their continuing consequences. However, it distinguished between the need to remedy those consequences and the much more extensive step of transferring beneficial ownership of copyright to Game Meats.
A constructive trust is a proprietary remedy with consequences extending beyond the immediate parties. In this case, its imposition would have provided Game Meats with rights associated with copyright ownership, including the potential to pursue third parties for copyright infringement.
The High Court considered that such an extensive remedy was unnecessary when more limited injunctive relief could adequately address the consequences of Farm Transparency's unlawful conduct.
The Court therefore set aside the declaration of constructive trust and the associated assignment requirement. It nevertheless ordered Farm Transparency to permanently delete or destroy the relevant images and copies within its possession or control, including copies that might come into its possession or control in the future.
The orders also required affidavits confirming compliance and imposed restrictions on publication or communication pending compliance.
Copyright ownership and unlawful conduct One of the most important aspects of the judgment is its treatment of the relationship between copyright ownership and the circumstances in which copyright material is created.
Under the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth), copyright ownership is determined by statutory rules concerning authorship, creation and ownership. The fact that a work is created in circumstances involving unlawful conduct does not necessarily mean that copyright fails to arise or automatically becomes the property of the person affected by that conduct.
The High Court's decision illustrates that distinction.
Farm Transparency's trespass provided a basis for legal remedies in favour of Game Meats. However, the existence of that wrong did not, without more, justify treating Game Meats as the beneficial owner of the copyright.
The Court's reasoning does not establish that a constructive trust can never be imposed over copyright created through unlawful activity. Rather, it emphasises the importance of identifying an appropriate equitable basis for such relief and considering whether a less intrusive remedy can adequately resolve the dispute.
This is particularly significant because a constructive trust may alter proprietary rights in ways that extend beyond the correction of the original wrongdoing. The importance of proportionality in equitable remedies The judgment also reinforces the principle that equitable relief should be tailored to the circumstances of the particular case.
Although equity may intervene where damages are inadequate, the availability of an equitable remedy does not mean that the most extensive form of relief should necessarily be granted.
In the present case, Game Meats had a legitimate interest in preventing the continued possession and exploitation of footage obtained through trespass. However, that interest could be protected through mandatory orders requiring deletion or destruction of the recordings.
Transferring beneficial ownership of the copyright was therefore unnecessary to achieve an appropriate remedial outcome.
The decision highlights the distinction between remedies designed to prevent the continuing consequences of unlawful conduct and remedies that confer proprietary rights on the injured party.
It also demonstrates that retaining copyright ownership does not necessarily confer a practical entitlement to retain, reproduce, publish or otherwise exploit the underlying material.